Home » Uncategorized » Fire, Fear and Unnaming in Berkeley, Budapest, and Parnassus Heights

Fire, Fear and Unnaming in Berkeley, Budapest, and Parnassus Heights

 

As the world knows, California is ablaze once again, and there is blame enough to go around–starting with Trump, our climate science denier-in-chief and crown prince of fossil fuel protection.

Despite the repeated charring of millions of acres of the Pacific northwest, as well as the planetary pandemic and social and economic collapse, we continue to engage in the pettiest local squabbles over race and gender, history and hearsay. Along with news from the so-called Cancel Culture come daily reports of moving and removing statues and statutes, un-naming and renaming schools, streets and soup kitchens.

In a rare glimmer of light from the murky swamp of identity politics, a 1936 mural on the history of medicine in California, seems likely to survive the demolition of the building that holds it.

The History of Medicine, by Bernard Zakheim in Toland auditorium, Parnassus Heights Campus, University of California, San Francisco

The mural, a fresco in a lecture hall on the Parnassus campus of the University of California, San Francisco, shows in one of its panels a Black nurse, Bridget (Biddy) Mason, ministering to a plague-stricken citizen. In this case the plague is malaria. But the point is that she is standing elbow-to-elbow with various bearded white elders of the Gold Rush state. To the right is a laboratory table where three of the hirsute gentlemen appear to be researching a vaccine or a cure. There is no sinister imperial or racist subtext to this scene’s narrative. Biddy Mason, a former slave, having worked as a midwife and healer, became known–in whatever order–as a church founder, a real estate entrepreneur, and a philanthropist. But how, in this time of racial and feminist turbulence, can this mural not be valued, and prominently displayed in the new Parnassus campus?

 

In 1945, my family moved to San Francisco so that my veteran father could study for an engineering degree. Meanwhile, my mother worked on Parnassus Avenue above Golden Gate Park at the medical center. My doughty little grandmother looked after me and my brother. Sometimes she walked us over to meet my mother after work, with me on my skates circling them self-importantly.

Parnassus Heights had been the site of the University of California’s first anthropology museum before it moved across the bay to Berkeley.

Tent city in Golden Gate Park after 1906 earthquake. Many sought medical help from the hospital at the Parnassus campus, visible in distance.

 In that old museum, Ishi, the “last wild Indian in America,” brought there in 1911 by the anthropologist Alfred Kroeber, spent the last five years of his life. He  chipped arrowheads, sang songs, and made fire for scores of fascinated visitors to the museum. Above the museum, Ishi had a brush hut, and perhaps a cave further up the slope.

 

Sixty years later, my anthropologist son traced the original hideout in the mountains where Ishi had survived as last of his tribe. He describes the networks of tribal and institutional interests that emerged as he recorded the saga of the search for Ishi’s brain and the repatriation of his remains (Ishi’s Brain, Orin Starn, Norton 2004).

Fifteen years later, in a related instance of identity politics, UC-Berkeley felt obliged to establish a Building Un-naming Review Committee to accommodate our recently reawakened anti-racist ardor. Kroeber Hall and the anthropology museum’s number soon came up.

Sadly, un-naming and other symbolic changes such as renaming buildings, seldom appear to affect the substance or tenor of what happens within them. In removal of monuments and names from our shared racist past, we run the risk of confusing re-branding with reform. With repentance, perhaps, for the many thousands of California Indians killed and displaced by the time Ishi was discovered.

Whether Alfred Kroeber was truly Ishi’s friend or merely his patron has been much discussed—most recently in the charges and counter-charges in the case of the “Un-naming” of Kroeber Hall. After a hundred years the issue is still unclear. No, Kroeber was not responsible for the wholesale excavation of Indian graves and mass storage of their bones. He did write a great deal about the California Indian cultures, did testify importantly about them to the Indian Affairs Commission. But yes, he did ship off Ishi’s brain to float in a tank at the Smithsonian Institution.

 

Unlike un-naming, toppling or defacing a statue has at least an immediate visual effect– not to mention another alternative, which is banishment to a civic graveyard of politically superannuated statues like that in Budapest.

 

Imre Nagy memorial near Parliament before his recent demotion

Last year saw the disappearance of a popular statue of Hungarian Resistance leader and anti-Soviet prime minister Imre Nagy. In a rather obvious maneuver of historic revision by the government, Nagy’s statue was shunted off to a less central location.

As yet there is no monumental statue of the current Hungarian autocrat, who presently has most cordial relations with Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump, if not with most leaders of western democracies.

Here Orban appears 25 years ago, eloquently denouncing the Russian occupation–at the ceremonial reburial–of none other than Imre Nagy.

But that was then and this is now.

 

 

It’s perhaps cheering to Viktor Orban’s detractors that the Budapest Memento Museum has space to accommodate any number of rejected politicians in the near or distant future.

 

 

And Kroeber Hall may be re-named after Ishi. Of course we don’t know his real name: “Ishi” was the word for “man” in his Yana language.

 

 

 

 


5 Comments

  1. anechka27 says:

    Dearest Francie,

    You put so much more aptly and succinctly the sentiment I’ve been trying to phrase “Despite the repeated charring of millions of acres of the Pacific northwest, as well as the planetary pandemic and social and economic collapse, we continue to engage in the pettiest local squabbles over race and gender, history and hearsay.” Thank you, as always, for writing with such precision, wit, and grace.

    How are you and Randy these days? I hear the air is a little better so maybe you’ve been able to resume outdoor meals? We have started work/school full time. It’s a bit bizarre to teach in masks to kids in plexi-glass enclosed desks, but their joy in being in person makes the trouble (almost?) worth it. Nicholas is also in school full time with fewer restrictions. Fingers crossed it lasts and everyone stays healthy. We are definitely remote-teaching Thanksgiving – end of January (if the school health holds), but I doubt we’ll be able to come to Ca with the necessary quarantines in both directions. I guess we’ll see.

    Love you so very much, and am thinking of you often. xoxoxooxxo a

    On Fri, Sep 18, 2020 at 8:09 PM frances smith starn wrote:

    > Frances Smith Starn posted: ” As the world knows, California is ablaze > once again, and there is blame enough to go around–starting with Trump, > our climate science denier-in-chief and crown prince of fossil fuel > protection. Despite the repeated charring of millions of acr” >

    Like

  2. Maureen Wesolowski says:

    As usual, so impressed by your facility (and envious of it !) there is a lovely french word for it, “faconde” — I just looked up the translation and got “loquacity”, which doesn’t roll off the tongue quite as well.

    Do you know who the demoted orator in that last photo is?

    A bientot,

    Love, M

    On Fri, Sep 18, 2020 at 5:09 PM frances smith starn wrote:

    > Frances Smith Starn posted: ” As the world knows, California is ablaze > once again, and there is blame enough to go around–starting with Trump, > our climate science denier-in-chief and crown prince of fossil fuel > protection. Despite the repeated charring of millions of acr” >

    Like

  3. Dan Slobin says:

    So well said: “we run the risk of confusing re-branding with reform.” What a frenzy of self-righteousness mixed with sincere righteousness. Can’t we have an American Memento Museum? Heine’s poem comes to mind, immortalized by Schumann: “Die alten, bösen Lieder,
    Die Träume bös’ und arg,
    Die lasst uns jetzt begraben,
    Holt einen grossen Sarg.”

    Like

  4. Gail Bensinger says:

    nice

    On Fri, Sep 18, 2020 at 5:09 PM frances smith starn wrote:

    > Frances Smith Starn posted: ” As the world knows, California is ablaze > once again, and there is blame enough to go around–starting with Trump, > our climate science denier-in-chief and crown prince of fossil fuel > protection. Despite the repeated charring of millions of acr” >

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: